What’s Open, Closed in Safety Harbor on Thanksgiving

Here's a look at dining options in town on Turkey Day 2012.

With one week to go before Thanksgiving, many people are deciding whether to dine at home or go somewhere to avoid the hassle of cooking for a small army.

Fortunately, Patch has you covered as far as where you can go - or not go - on Turkey day. Plus, we'll tell you where you can find traditional pies, unconventional cupcakes, and even a unique smoked bird for your dinner. 

Here’s a look at what some local establishments are doing this Thanksgiving. If you think of anyplace we missed, or you have a question about one we didn’t mention, please let us know in the comments below.

Open for dinner:

Paradise Restaurant

  • Where: 443 Main St.
  • What: The downtown landmark is serving a special menu for Thanksgiving, including fresh roasted turkey with stuffing, lamb shank and ham steak dinners, all served with choice of potato or vegetable, soup or salad and homemade dessert
  • Cost: $9.95, add $2.00 to upgrade dessert to slice of pie
  • When: Thursday, November 22, 7am – 4pm
  • Also: Bring in a canned good and receive a free homemade dessert. Canned donations will go to a local food pantry
  • Contact: 727-725-1208

Order a turkey:

Brady’s Backyard BBQ

  • Where: 340 Main St.
  • What: Brady’s will be taking its annual smoked turkey orders from now until Thanksgiving Day, but don’t wait till the last minute to order these mouthwatering 11-14-lb. birds. Brady says he will only have about 20-25 available, and once they’re preordered, they’re gone.
  • Cost: $49.95
  • When: Order the turkeys now for pick-up either the day before Thanksgiving after 11:30am or on Thanksgiving Day between 10am – 11am only
  • Contact: 727-712-3727

Traditional desserts:

Peace, Love and Cake

  • Where: 839 Main St.
  • What: Fresh pies, cakes, cupcakes and all sorts of tasty pastry treats. Owner Sarah Hill says she will have all the traditional favorite pies like pumpkin, apple, pecan and key lime, as well as wide assortment of additional desserts
  • Cost: Prices vary
  • When: Order up until Thanksgiving Day
  • Contact: 727-530-9700


First Quality Sausage House

  • Where: 605 9th Ave. N.
  • What: The longtime butcher shop/bakery fills many needs during the holiday season, with everything from its fresh smoked meats to its homemade breads. Looking for a delicious dessert? The fresh strudel at the Sausage House is the stuff of legend, according to owner Aniko Rakozci.
  • Contact: 727-725-5705


-The Mattie Williams Neighborhood Family Center will host its annual free Thanksgiving meal again this year on Thanksgiving Day. The facility, located at 1003 Dr. Martin Luther King Street North, feeds not only the homeless and underprivileged, but anyone who wishes to spend the holiday in the company of others in the community. Contact the center at 727-791-8255 for more information. 


-The following restaurants will be closed on Thanksgiving Day:

  • Green Springs Bistro
  • Parts of Paris French Bistro
  • Southern Fresh
  • Nantucket Bucket
  • Cello’s Char-House
  • Tapping the Vine
  • Crispers
  • Whistle Stop
Gisela Bennie November 15, 2012 at 04:56 PM
Jeff - you are so diplomatic! Thanks for this info.
Jeffrey Rosenfield November 15, 2012 at 04:57 PM
I've got to be, Gisela! :)
Sunde Farquhar November 16, 2012 at 12:43 PM
Thanks for keeping us Safety Harbor residents informed, Jeff! Very informative article :) I bet lots of people will be looking for this info leading up to Thanksgiving!
jarine November 22, 2012 at 03:44 PM
Thanks Jeff! The Spa has a nice Thanksgiving buffet planned and Safety Harbor Grille is open and serving Thanksgiving dinner.
Jeffrey Rosenfield November 22, 2012 at 05:32 PM
Thanks Jarine! Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »